In this paper, the food waste valorization alternatives are evaluated from a sustainability point of view. Using food waste characteristics as input data, we estimate the sustainable benefits such as energy utilization and GHG emission reduction for each potential food waste processing technique. Additionally, the sustainable benefits of reverse logistics of food waste are quantified based upon geographic distance and valorization characteristics. We formulate the food waste network framework as a strategic linear programming (LP) model that aims to minimize total food waste management cost while satisfying emissions and energy use constraints. Given the recent regulations of the commercial food material disposal ban, we test the efficiency of the proposed framework by designing a sustainable food waste treatment network for the state of Massachusetts. Results show that with a marginal increase in the treatment cost of food waste, the model has achieved zero net emissions, zero net energy use, and a competitive overall sustainability impact. Thus, by utilizing the food waste network model, policymakers can achieve the best sustainable strategies for the food waste management.